"The two meetings last week make it crystal clear," Randy Gordon, president of the Columbia Street Waterfront Association, wrote after back-to-back public sessions in early October. "The Brooklyn Marine Terminal redevelopment and the BQE Central projects are on a collision course, with our neighborhood caught between." Brooklyn Downtown Star reported his comments in its coverage of the city's first BQE Central info session on October 6.
Both projects start at the same place, the foot of Atlantic Avenue where Cobble Hill meets the water. Both also have public input windows that close within days of each other this month. Two different agencies run them, and each asks the public about its own project.
Where the Two Projects Meet
NYC DOT's BQE Central covers the roughly 1.5-mile, city-owned stretch of the expressway between Atlantic Avenue and Sands Street. That includes the triple cantilever beneath the Brooklyn Heights Promenade. The city owns about 12% of the BQE in Brooklyn, and New York State owns the rest. The trench running through Cobble Hill is outside DOT's project limits. Its southern boundary is Atlantic Avenue.
The Brooklyn Marine Terminal begins on the other side of that intersection. It is a 122-acre site running from Pier 7 at Atlantic Avenue south to Pier 12 at Wolcott Street in Red Hook. The highway project ends at Atlantic Avenue, and the port project starts there. DOT's proposed construction bypass would also start there. That is a temporary two-level structure carrying both directions of traffic over Furman Street from Atlantic Avenue to Columbia Heights, no higher than the existing Queens-bound level.
DOT has said it is coordinating with the terminal project. Tiffany-Ann Taylor leads the DOT team working on the BQE and also represents the agency in the terminal negotiations. "We are in very close coordination," she said at the October 6 session. The public comment processes are still separate, with separate meetings, documents and deadlines.
What DOT Is Asking About
DOT plans to rehabilitate the highway, not rebuild it. The work covers deck, wall and joint repairs, plus drainage, railings and lighting. The highway would stay two lanes, and the interchanges would not change. The stated goal is about 40 more years of service life. Construction is expected to start in 2029 and finish by 2040, including building and removing the bypass. Taylor put the cost at nearly $4 billion. "Trust me, nobody wants to spend nearly $4 billion," she told the room. "But here we are."
What is open now is the scope of the environmental review, not the design. DOT released a Draft Scope of Work on October 2. It lists what the Environmental Impact Statement will study, including transportation, noise, air quality, parks and open space, historic resources and neighborhood character. During scoping, the public can name issues that should be studied and comment on the study areas. Once the period closes, DOT writes a Final Scope, and the Draft EIS follows in 2027.
For Cobble Hill, the scope decides how closely the EIS looks at what happens at its corner during more than a decade of construction. It sets the boundaries of the traffic and noise studies, and whether the study area reaches past Atlantic Avenue.
One more detail matters later in the process. Brooklyn Downtown Star reported that the project would need a parkland alienation bill in Albany because it would take a corner of Squibb Park.
What EDC Is Drawing
The terminal is further along on paper and less settled in practice. The Advisory Task Force approved a Vision Plan in September 2025. The plan allows up to about 6,000 homes, about 40% of them affordable, alongside a modernized, all-electric port. Politico put the cost at $3.5 billion. NYCEDC's July 2026 materials place 3,800 of those homes in BMT North, the part of the site directly across from Cobble Hill and the Columbia Street Waterfront District.
Several items in the Vision Plan sit within a few blocks of Cobble Hill:
- A Pier 7 destination park. The plan describes an 11-acre park around Pier 7 that adjoins Brooklyn Bridge Park.
- A neighborhood park at Columbia and Degraw. The plan sets aside 1.7 acres at that corner, as part of at least 28 acres of public open space across the whole site.
- Building heights at Pier 7. The plan caps housing on the Pier 7 uplands at 1,000 units. The July presentation lists a 425-foot maximum building height there. The neighboring Quay Tower, which the plan uses as a reference point, is about 300 feet tall.
The terminal is going through a state-led General Project Plan, so it bypasses the city's land use review. NYCEDC expects the Draft EIS, including traffic projections, and the draft GPP in the first quarter of 2027.
The renderings from the October 21 Task Force session are labeled for discussion only. The deck notes that no site has a proposed design and that the street, greenway and open space designs are conceptual.
The Trucks Connect the Two Projects
The clearest link between the two processes is truck traffic. The 2025 Vision Plan sent port trucks in at the Hamilton Avenue and Bowne Street intersections, steering them toward Hamilton Avenue. The October 21 Task Force deck moves the container port entrance and exit to Bowne and Summit Streets along Conover Street. The deck says this "enables direct connection to the BQE" and responds to feedback asking to reduce truck presence on neighborhood streets.
So the port's truck plan depends on the BQE, while DOT plans more than a decade of construction on the BQE north of Atlantic Avenue. The port's own capital work is already moving. NYCEDC expects a new electric crane at Pier 10 to be operating in the first quarter of 2027. In the Downtown Star account, Gordon's complaint was that the latest terminal presentation, given the day after DOT's forum, did not mention the BQE project. Both November processes take questions on transportation. They are the place to raise how the two projects affect each other.
The November Calendar
The dates fall in a tight sequence. As of publication on Thursday, November 5:
- Thursday, November 5. This is the registration deadline for language interpretation at DOT's virtual scoping meeting.
- Tuesday, November 10, 6:30 to 8:30 p.m. DOT holds an in-person scoping meeting at The Auditorium at City Tech, 285 Jay Street. Interpretation is provided in Spanish, Mandarin, Cantonese, Arabic and ASL.
- Thursday, November 12, 6:30 to 8:30 p.m. DOT's virtual scoping meeting on Zoom requires registration in advance. Both meetings present the same material.
- Wednesday, November 18, 6 to 8 p.m. The Cobble Hill Association hosts a free workshop with NYCEDC designers at Christ Church, 326 Clinton Street. Designers will present visuals and take questions on design, public use and transportation for the terminal. The Association asks for RSVPs. EDC also plans other workshops during November.
- Thursday, November 19, 6 to 8 p.m. The Cobble Hill Association's annual fall meeting returns to Christ Church, with elected officials taking questions.
- Monday, November 23. Comments on BQE Central's Draft Scope of Work must arrive by this date.
DOT accepts comments four ways: through its online form, which caps comments at 512 characters, by email to [email protected], by mail to the BQE Central Project Team at 55 Water Street, or at either scoping meeting. Full instructions are on the BQE Central project page. Longer comments fit better in email or a letter.
The Christ Church sessions sit between the two DOT meetings and the November 23 deadline. That gives residents a chance to see the latest terminal concepts before filing a BQE comment. Louis Cox of the Cobble Hill Association serves on the terminal's Advisory Task Force, alongside Mike Racioppo of Brooklyn Community Board 6.
What November Will Not Settle
The BQE scope will be final once DOT answers the comments. Much more of the terminal is still open. In May, Politico reported that the PILOT financing authorization for the project was left out of the state budget because of opposition in the Assembly, where Assembly Member Jo Anne Simon has been among the project's leading critics. State Senator Andrew Gounardes, who represents the area, told Politico the redevelopment "ultimately cannot proceed" without it and said he expected lawmakers to take it up again in the next session.
Traffic has been the main local concern from the start. At a June 2025 City Council hearing, Council Member Alexa Avilés asked, "How do you expect a community to support a plan that doesn't have a completed, full transportation study?" The Brooklyn Eagle reported her question. In the same article, the Eagle reported the Cobble Hill Association's 2025 position, which acknowledged the plan's transit, ferry, shuttle and bike proposals but said they did not resolve the "big question" of traffic from the new housing. That full transportation study is the Draft EIS due in early 2027. DOT's own Draft EIS for the highway is due the same year.
Both reviews will publish traffic numbers for the same intersection in 2027. What each one studies is being decided this month, and the Christ Church sessions are where Cobble Hill residents can raise the overlap in person.
If you own on or near the Columbia Street side of Cobble Hill and want to talk through what these timelines could mean for your property, The New York Collaborative offers a bespoke market consultation grounded in the documents above. Our Cobble Hill neighborhood page is a good place to start.